This article refers to the P.S.1 exhibition YAP 10th Anniversary Review
nARCHITECTS won the 2004 YAP competition with Canopy, a paradise of shaped bamboo with many distinct climactic environments for different modes of lounging.
P.S.1: What was the process leading up to your presentation to the committee? And what was it like working with the museum after you’d won?
Mimi Hoang and Eric Bunge, nArchitects : We participated in the fifth year of the competition so we talked to the past four winners to figure out what was plausible. From Lindy Roy’s team we learned not to dig because the ground is really hard. From Tom Wiscombe we learned not to paint anything because it would chip and peel. From SHoP we learned to tailor the construction design method to really try to convince the committee that we could build it. The presentation is very much about how the project can be built.
P.S.1: What were the parameters of the project? How was your approach to the competition different from the other competitors?
nA: Our year was the first year that landscape architects were invited to submit; the jury was interested in this dialogue as a part of the competition. We took that literally and that was one of the reasons why we chose bamboo as our material. We were trying to think about the site in a new way and didn’t want it to be only about the ground surface but also about wall surfaces. We called our strategy a “deep-landscape” strategy, a way of suturing site conditions together. It was important that we use one material to come up with a tectonic system that would address the ground, shade, seating, and structure. It was interesting to use an organic, low-tech, third-world material but to do it in a very precise and engineered way.
P.S.1: You’re talking about the idea of “deep-landscape” but I wonder how you dealt with program, or with the idea of WarmUp?
nA: We tried very hard not to fix an idea of “program,” or take a prescriptive approach. For us, it’s more about the amenities, the conditions, the attributes of environments. We started by saying that we wanted a really large gesture; we wanted it to be the biggest one yet! And also the tallest one! Simple ambition! We wanted it to soar above the crowd so that it would be visible when there’s a crowd of 8,000 people, but also so that it would still feel intimate on a Sunday.
This interview was conducted by Chris Barley and Troy Conrad Therrien, recent graduates of the Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation at Columbia University. As students they collected an image archive and condicuted an oral history project on YAP for a seminar with Barry Bergdoll, the Philip Johnson Chief Curator of Architecture and Design at MoMA. They were asked to collaborate with P.S.1 to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the program by organizing an exhibition of the images collected and offering their oral histories to be edited and published in the Summer 2009 P.S.1 Newspaper. They will continue this research as part of their on-going project, "Youth Value", on youth in architecture.
A History of YAP: If These Walls Could Talk
Ellinger/Yehia Design: Making it Real
nArchitects: Walking in a Bamboo Wonderland
Q&A with Young Architects: MOS 2009
Gage/Clemenceau Architects: The Golden Rule
Cho Slade: Falling from the Skies
Q&A with Young Architects: Gnuform 2006
Q&A with Young Architects: KDLAB 2002
Q&A with Young Architects: L.E.FT 2009
Q&A with the YAP Jury: Barry Bergdoll
Q&A with the YAP Jury: Terence Riley
Q&A with the YAP Jury: Antoine Guerrero
Q&A with the YAP Jury: Andres Lepik
Q&A with the YAP Jury: Klaus Biesenbach
Q&A with the YAP Jury: Peter Reed
Q&A with Young Architects: MONAD 2008
Q&A with Young Architects: LOT-EK 2000
Q&A with Young Architects: SYSTEMArchitects 2001/2003
THEM (Lynch + Crembil): Building a Structure, Building a Network
Q&A with Young Architects: IWAMOTOSCOTT 2006
Q&A with Young Architects: Studio SUMO 2001
Q&A with Young Architects: Taeg Nishimoto 2000
Matter Practice: Earthly Delights
PARA-Project: Excess as a Resource
Q&A with Young Architects: !ndie Architecture 2009
Q&A with Young Architects: Griffin Enright Architects 2004
Q&A with Young Architects: su11 architecture+design 2008
Forsythe + MacAllen Design / molo: Winning Isn't Everything
Material Lab: Changing Conditions
Bade Stageberg Cox: Beyond the Usual Approach